Adolescence - Capable to be Culpable?
Adolescents are often taught to become adults before their bodies are physically capable of being adults. The frontal and pre-frontal cortex which control reasoning, organization, judgment and foresight is still beginning to develop within teens and young adults. The frontal lobe may still be in the developing stage when one is as old as 22 years old.
Gray matter, which involves “thoughts” is in mass-production at the time of adolescence. Having so much gray matter, the brian begins to “trim” and get rid of it. In its place grows white matter, which insulates the brain and brain cells, promoting precision in thoughts and actions. Do to lack of judgment, the teens rely on “gut” feelings and emotions. This causes the teen or young adult to be brash and impulsive. The frontal lobe helps control these impulses.
So, can an adolescent be held accountable for all of their actions? Jay Giedd from the National Institute of Mental Health states, “part of the brain that is helping organization, planning and strategizing is not done being built yet…. It’s sort of unfair to expect to have adult levels of organizational skills or decision making before their brain is finished being built.” What about being held accountable for crimes?
Dr. Chris Mallett surveyed juveniles on death row about abuse and violence in their past. The data:
- 74% experienced family dysfunction
- 60% were victims of abuse and/or neglect
- 43% had a diagnosed psychiatric disorder
- 38% suffered from substance addictions
- 38% lived in poverty
In 1987, 14 juveniles one death row were included in an investigation. 9 of the 14 had neuropsychological disorders and 7 had psychotic disorders since early childhood. The lag and difficulties of not having a fully developed frontal lobe can cause teens to have desperate and poor decisions. 20 - 30% of high school students consider suicide.
Are adolescents given as much of a chance as adults? Are they truly capable of being culpable? While adolescents are less able to make good decisions, have good foresight, have good judgment, and be competent, teens, in this time of molding and change, are more capable of rehabilitation. In many cases, adolescents should be reevaluated and possibly given a second chance. Those who committed serious crimes may have a psychological evaluation and/or have correction - rehab.